Is Mexico Too Dangerous Now, or Are Warnings Exaggerated?

The Statistics Tell a Complex Story

When you look at Mexico's murder rates, the numbers can be pretty jarring at first glance. The national homicide rate fell slightly from 25.9 per 100,000 in 2022 to 24.9 per 100,000 in 2023, but that's still way higher than most countries we'd consider safe.

To put this in perspective, Mexico experienced a drop in its murder rate to 19.3 in 2024, from 24 the previous year, showing some improvement. But here's what's really interesting - security analysts estimate that around two-thirds of homicides are committed by organized crime.

This means most violence isn't randomly targeting regular people or tourists; it's criminals fighting other criminals. Though homicide rates have dropped marginally, the country still reports over thirty thousand crime-related deaths per year.

The reality is that Mexico's violence problem is real, but it's not evenly spread across the country or affecting everyone equally.

Tourist Areas Have Different Safety Profiles

Overall, many parts of Mexico remain safe for tourists who follow basic precautions, and this is backed up by actual visitor experiences. Think about it this way - there were more than 36.7 million visits by Americans to Mexico in 2023, and the vast majority of these people came home with nothing worse than a sunburn.

There has been no evidence the organizations have targeted or are targeting holiday travelers or civilians that are not related to illicit activity, and incidents of concern are virtually non-existent in and around tourist areas. The Mexican government has also stepped up security in popular destinations, with thousands of special forces sent to the resort areas along the Mexican Riviera, including Cancun, Playa del Carmen, and Tulum.

Even tourism industry experts who live and work in these areas feel confident about safety - they wouldn't put their own families at risk.

The Media Magnification Effect

Here's something that really skews our perception: violent incidents involving tourists make international headlines, while the millions of peaceful vacations don't. Incidents in Mexico involving tourists are extremely few and far between, and when stuff does happen in tourist destinations, tourists generally aren't involved.

It's like how plane crashes get massive news coverage even though flying is statistically safer than driving to the airport. We could single out cases of gang violence and shootings in popular US cities like Los Angeles, New York, Miami, or Las Vegas, despite these four cities being some of the most popular tourist destinations in the US.

The availability heuristic tricks our brains into thinking dramatic, memorable events are more common than they actually are. This doesn't mean we should ignore risks entirely, but we need to keep things in perspective.

Where the Real Danger Zones Actually Are

Not all of Mexico is created equal when it comes to safety. Six states—Colima, Guerrero, Michoacan, Sinaloa, Tamaulipas, and Zacatecas—have been given a flat "do not travel" warning because of the risks of crime and kidnapping.

With a homicide rate of 101 per 100,000 people in 2024, Colima stands out for its extreme levels of violence, caught in the crossfire of violent turf wars between powerful cartels. Meanwhile, the states closest to the U.S.

border are some of the most dangerous due to their importance to the drug trade, and visitors should avoid unnecessary travel to most of the states that border the U.S. But here's the key point - most tourists aren't heading to these places anyway.

The popular beach destinations and colonial cities that fill up travel brochures are in completely different areas with much lower crime rates.

Cancun's Safety Reality Check

Let's talk about Cancun specifically, since it's probably Mexico's most famous tourist destination. In 2024, Cancun's homicide rate was about 64 per 100,000 residents, which sounds scary until you realize that the 2024 homicide rate in St.

Louis, Missouri was 69.4 per 100,000 residents, cementing it as the "murder capital of the US". The murders have largely been local crimes, and the tourist deaths have been cases where they were in the wrong place at the wrong time.

All-inclusive properties have really stepped up their security measures, and resorts have done a great job securing their properties - when you pull up to the gate, if your name's not on the clipboard, they won't even let you pass through. The reality is that if you're staying at a resort and following basic safety guidelines, your risk level drops dramatically.

The Safest Parts of Mexico Keep Getting Overlooked

While everyone focuses on the dangerous areas, Mexico has some genuinely safe regions that rarely make the news. Yucatán was again ranked as the most peaceful, followed by Tlaxcala, Durango, Chiapas, and Nayarit according to the Mexico Peace Index.

The average homicide rate in Mexico's five least peaceful states was 73 per 100,000 people, compared to 8.2 per 100,000 in its five most peaceful states, showing there's a massive difference depending on where you go. The Yucatán Peninsula is the safest place for Americans to drive in 2024, according to the US State Department.

States like Yucatán have crime rates comparable to many safe countries, but they don't get the attention because "Mexico is pretty safe in some places" doesn't grab headlines like "American tourist killed in Mexico" does.

Government Travel Warnings Are Overly Broad

The U.S. State Department issues travel advisories that are designed to cover every possible scenario, which leads to some pretty sweeping warnings.

Mexico has the most active State Department travel advisories of any country in the world, partly because the State Department has assigned different levels of travel safety to Mexico's states. The government's warnings are really designed with safety in mind, but they can be overly broad, with advisories that warn crime and violence can occur anywhere, at any time, even in resort areas.

The same warning could apply to visiting New York City or any major American destination. Much of the high-profile violent crime reported in Mexico is related to organized criminal groups and often occurs away from primary tourist areas, though incidents can sometimes affect bystanders.

These warnings serve a legal purpose for the government, but they don't necessarily reflect the actual risk level for typical tourists.

Spring Break and Party Destinations Need Extra Caution

While Mexico might be safer than headlines suggest, certain situations and destinations do require more awareness. The U.S.

Embassy issued a broader safety message ahead of spring break, warning of crime, drug-related incidents, unregulated alcohol, and sexual assault in downtown areas of Cancun, Playa del Carmen, and Tulum. Crime, including violent crime, can occur anywhere in Mexico, including in popular tourist destinations, and U.S.

citizens should exercise increased caution in the downtown areas of popular spring break locations, especially after dark. The combination of heavy drinking, unfamiliar surroundings, and the party atmosphere creates risks that don't exist when you're sipping cocktails at an all-inclusive resort during the day.

Drugs are the main source of crime involving tourists in Mexico, and the cartels are active around popular resort areas because they have clients at the resorts. Young tourists who go looking for drugs or venture into sketchy areas late at night are putting themselves in harm's way.

The Violence Is Getting More Targeted and Specific

Here's something that doesn't get talked about enough - most of Mexico's violence problem stems from organized crime fighting each other, not targeting random people. The rise in violence in Mexico is strongly tied to organised crime, which has evolved over the past decade in response to changing drug consumption trends in the U.S.

market, with the shift toward synthetic drugs like fentanyl being up to 50 times stronger than heroin and potentially 2,700 times more profitable. Since 2007, the estimated number of organised crime-related homicides has increased sixfold—from about 3,000 to nearly 18,000 in 2024.

Most homicides are targeted assassinations against members of criminal organizations, and battles for territory between criminal groups have resulted in violent crime in areas frequented by U.S. citizens, though bystanders have been injured or killed in shooting incidents.

The violence is horrible, but it's not random - it's business disputes between criminals that occasionally spill over into public spaces.

Economic Stakes Keep Tourism Areas Safer

There's a powerful economic incentive for Mexico to keep tourist areas safe, and this actually works in visitors' favor. Tourism generated 4.7 million jobs in 2023, and the tourism industry has to deal with the significant challenge of the crisis of generalized violence in Mexico.

The government has deployed over 8,000 troops in the main Mexican tourist destinations, and despite warnings, tourism appears to be relatively unaffected, with over 6.6 million international tourists arriving by air in January-March 2024, a 7.4% increase compared to the same period last year. Local authorities, businesses, and even criminal organizations have vested interests in keeping tourist zones functioning smoothly.

Everyone has a vested interest in making travel to Cancun fun, exciting, memorable, and above all safe, with the belief that 'our house is your house'. Violence is bad for business, and Mexico's economy depends heavily on tourism revenue.

Personal Safety Measures Make a Huge Difference

The gap between a safe trip and a dangerous one often comes down to common-sense precautions that many travelers ignore. Tourists are rarely the targets of violent crime, and following basic safety precautions like not going out alone at night and refraining from wearing flashy jewelry minimizes your risk of being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

It's best practice to stick to areas with large tourist presences and avoid driving through surrounding rural areas, though popular tourist destinations are safer in general, there are still significant risks that travelers should plan around. Don't travel at night outside major cities, and use major toll roads wherever possible or access cities directly by air travel.

The tourists who get into trouble are often the ones who throw caution to the wind, venture into areas they shouldn't, or get involved with activities they should avoid. Smart travelers who stay alert and make good decisions rarely have problems.

The Bottom Line on Mexico's Safety

So is Mexico too dangerous, or are the warnings exaggerated? The honest answer is both and neither.

Although peace has improved slightly in the past five years, Mexico remains considerably less peaceful than in 2015, and organised crime continues to drive extreme violence. The country absolutely has serious violence problems that affect real people's lives every day.

But for tourists who stick to established destinations, use common sense, and don't go looking for trouble, the actual risk level is much lower than sensational headlines would suggest. Although a travel advisory is in effect, tourists flock to Mexico every year without incident, and traveling anywhere requires a little bit of safety precaution.

The key is understanding that Mexico isn't uniformly dangerous - it's a large, diverse country where your safety largely depends on where you go, what you do, and how smart you are about it. You wouldn't judge all of America based on the most dangerous neighborhoods in Detroit or Chicago, so why judge all of Mexico based on cartel violence in border states?

Get more from Travelbucketlist!

What do you think about this topic? Share your thoughts in the comments below — we would love to hear from you! Want more stories like this? Follow us and never miss out!