Historic Lancaster County parish house up for sale

LANCASTER, Pa. (WHTM) — A historic home in the City of Lancaster that was built in the 1800s as a parish house has been listed for sale at $450,000.

According to the listing, this home that is situated in the heart of Lancaster City’s Historic District is located on 44 East Orange Street. The historic home was first built back in 1850 and was utilized as a parish house for the next-door First Reformed Church.

Today, the home serves as a parsonage for the church.

The listing says this 2,786-square-foot detached brick home is commercially zoned making it perfect for those looking to combine home and business – specifically, it could be ideal for attorneys, non-profits, wellness professionals, creatives or families.

The property features 5 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, along with original architectural details.

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

  • Courtesy of Danielle Beattie & Brian Philips Photography

Furthermore, the historic home shares a charming courtyard with the First Reformed Church, offering a serene setting for future owners.

This parish house is situated in the City of Lancaster municipality and is part of the School District of Lancaster. The home was listed by Keller Williams Elite Real Estate and the listing agent for the property is Daniele Beattie.

abc27 features unique properties for sale in the area. These listings are not sponsored and are featured solely for their unique characteristics.

Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.