'Gilligan's Island': Untold Secrets of the Classic Castaway Comedy

It's one of the most enduring openings in television history: a "three-hour tour" gone wrong that strands seven people-soon to be known as the castaways-on a desert island. But for all its sunny slapstick and coconut-powered contraptions, Gilligan's Island started as something quite different-a satire with surprising ambition.

"Like Bewitched, the pilot was shot the week President Kennedy was assassinated," recalls pop culture historian, writer and producer Geoffrey Mark. "Part of it was even filmed in Hawaii. It was the only time they went on location like that." But that pilot was not the show series creator Sherwood Schwartz had originally envisioned. And it wasn't the one CBS wanted, either.

According to Mark, Schwartz imagined Gilligan's Island as a humorous microcosm of American society in 1964. "He wanted this to be an examination of different kinds of people-different classes, values, perspectives-who would be forced to coexist. He wanted it to be satirical, but he didn't want it to be silly or pander to children. Unfortunately, CBS didn't even understand what the word ‘microcosm' meant, which Schwartz told me directly."

The original 'Gilligan's Island' cast

Entertainment

Meet the Forgotten 'Gilligan's Island' Cast Members from the Unaired Pilot

When you think of Gilligan's Island-or find yourself singing the show's iconic theme song-chances are you'll find yourself reciting the names of all seven castaways with little problem: Gilligan, the Skipper, too; the millionaire and his wife, the movie star, the Professor and Mary Ann. But what many fans don't realize is that the very […]

The network's idea of "funny" was goofier and they pushed for changes early on, even before the first pilot was completed. "They fought over what the show was actually going to be," he says. "Sherwood wanted something deeper, not a cartoon. But he also wanted to get a show on the air and CBS had other ideas."

‘Gilligan's Island': the early days

So, the original pilot was compromised from the start. "What they came up with was: two rich people, a real smart, good-looking all-American guy and two witty all-American girls," Mark observes. "The Skipper was supposed to be a real skipper, someone responsible and nautical. Gilligan was the wildcard-the unknown. This wasn't supposed to be a Bob Denver sitcom."

CBS, however, wanted Denver-he had been a hit as Maynard G. Krebs on The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis-and they pushed hard for him. In the unaired pilot, Denver's Gilligan was a bit more subdued. But the rest of the cast? "Other than the Howells, it just lies there," Mark says. "They're all white-breaded mayonnaise. There's no reason to watch the show."

Bob Denver, 1959, 1964, 1974

Entertainment

A Look at the 7 Shows 'Gilligan's Island' Actor Bob Denver Starred In

Bob Denver is best known for 'Gilligan's Island,' but he was the lead actor in a total of seven television series

The network agreed. "CBS was terribly concerned. ‘What are you going to do for 32 weeks a season with these people?' they asked. They didn't like the pilot. They pretty much told Sherwood, ‘Get lost.'"

That could have been the end of it-until Schwartz brought in reinforcements. His older brother Al, a seasoned comedy writer from radio and variety shows, teamed up with a writer named Austin "Rocky" Kalish, who typically worked with his wife. Together, Al and Rocky stepped in to retool the show. "They created Ginger and Mary Ann," Mark reveals. "That wasn't Sherwood."

Gilligan's Island, (from left): Dawn Wells, Tina Louise

Gilligan's Island (from left): Dawn Wells, Tina Louise

While praising him as a lovely man, he also points out that Schwartz had what he calls "founder's amnesia." "He never gave Al and Rocky any credit for creating those characters. They never got a piece of the show."

As for rumors that Dawn Wells (Mary Ann) had a different contract and received residuals? Not true, Mark insists. "There's been a rumor for years that only Dawn got points on the show, but that's false. They all had the same contract. None of them got points."

THE HONEYMOONERS, Jackie Gleason, Audrey Meadows, Art Carney, Joyce Randolph, 1955-56

Entertainment

'The Honeymooners' On Set: Rare Photos of Jackie Gleason & Art Carney

"The Classic 39" is oftentimes the way people refer to The Honeymooners, the 1955 to 1956 sitcom focusing on working-class Brooklyn bus driver Ralph Kramden (Jackie Gleason), his sharp-tongued wife Alice (Audrey Meadows), best friend and sewer worker Ed Norton (Art Carney) and his wife, Trixie (Joyce Randolph). What few realize-or remember-is that the premise […]

That myth, he notes, likely stems from another sitcom legend. "Audrey Meadows had residuals written into her contract for The Honeymooners when it went from live variety to the filmed 39 episodes. And people were, like, ‘Who's going to watch this again?' Well, we know how that turned out."

From satire to slapstick

Bob Denver as Gilligan from the opening credits of Gilligan's Island.

Bob Denver as Gilligan from the opening credits of Gilligan's Island.

While Sherwood Schwartz had pitched Gilligan's Island as a smart satire, CBS had other ideas. "They wanted it to appeal to kids," Geoffrey Mark explains. "So, Sherwood was heavily leaned on to put in copious amounts of slapstick." The shift was dramatic: what had been conceived as a layered commentary on class and society was now expected to fit alongside broad comedies like My Favorite Martian and The Munsters.

"It wasn't supposed to be a Bob Denver sitcom," Mark reminds us. "But CBS liked Bob because of Dobie Gillis. They felt a Maynard G. Krebs-type character would work on the island." And Denver delivered-just not the Gilligan Schwartz originally envisioned.

Autographed portrait of Bob Denver, wearing a goatee and sitting on the floor, for the television show 'The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis'.

Autographed portrait of Bob Denver, wearing a goatee and sitting on the floor, for the television show The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis.

Casting challenges extended beyond the titular character. In the unaired pilot, the Professor was played by a different actor-John Gabriel who was deemed, in Mark's words, "too masculine, too good-looking, too threatening." The concern? "CBS thought the people at home might believe that, when we're not watching, the Professor is sleeping with everybody on the island."

The part was recast with Russell Johnson, who had a long history in TV dramas but brought a more restrained presence. Mark, who was personally close with Johnson, recalls that at his audition, "the first thing they asked Russell to do was take off his shirt." Ironically, Johnson was never shirtless on the show. "It's the only time anybody ever asked to look at his body before he even said a word," Mark says, quoting Johnson himself.

Casting Mary Ann… and building the lagoon

Dawn Wells in 'Gilligan's Island' 1960s

Dawn Wells in Gilligan's Island

Casting Mary Ann came through a CBS executive named Ethel Winant. "Ethel cast four shows for CBS-if they needed help, she was the one," Mark says. "It was her idea to bring in Dawn Wells." Wells had been steadily working, with small parts on Bonanza and in a film with Barbara Eden but was still early in her career.

But while the final cast began to gel, the production remained tricky-especially in terms of logistics. Even though the pilot had included location footage from Hawaii, the series itself would be filmed entirely in Los Angeles. The island set was created on the CBS Studio Center lot. "It was tiny," Mark says, "but by using wonderful camera angles, it looked huge in promos. There are photos where it looks like the island stretches forever-but it didn't."

Sherwood Schwartz with the cast of Gilligan's Island

Entertainment

‘Gilligan's Island' and Sherwood Schwartz: His Son Shares Untold Stories

There aren't many television series that have remained a part of pop culture in the way that Gilligan's Island has. The show, which ran from 1964 to 1967, started with a pretty simple premise of seven people from different walks of life finding themselves stranded on a desert island. And while it was something the […]

Over time, that iconic lagoon became less and less a part of studio history. "They cemented in all but a little bit of it, and then finally, several years ago, they just paved over it," Mark says. "There's a little sign where it used to be, but that's all that's left."

Despite the tropical visuals and cheerful tone, the set wasn't exactly a paradise. "It was not necessarily the happiest set in the world," Mark admits. "There was stress right from the beginning."

Tensions, typecasting and Tina Louise

Tina Louise as Ginger Grant from the opening credits of Gilligan's Island.

Tina Louise as Ginger Grant from the opening credits of ‘Gilligan's Island.'

For all its breezy charm onscreen, Gilligan's Island was something of a shipwreck of clashing egos and broken expectations behind the scenes-nowhere more evident than with Tina Louise, the show's resident movie star.

"Tina was starring on Broadway as the second female lead in a Julie Styne musical called Fade Out – Fade In, opposite Carol Burnett," explains Geoffrey Mark. "It wasn't a blockbuster, but it was running." Then her agent came calling with a big opportunity: CBS was producing a sitcom about a movie star stranded on a desert island and they wanted Tina immediately.

Carol Burnett and Tina Louise in 'Fade Out-Fade In'

Carol Burnett and Tina Louise in Fade Out-Fade In

The catch? She had to buy herself out of her Broadway contract. "The agent lied to her," Mark says bluntly. "In those days, a second lead in a Broadway show might make $800–$1,000 a week. A series regular on a sitcom was making thousands." And with the agent taking 10%, it's no mystery what motivated the push. Tina walked away from Broadway-and into a situation she wasn't ready for.

"She sits down at the first read-through of the rewritten pilot," Mark says. "She's flipping pages, flipping pages and finally says, ‘Excuse me. We're on page 10. The show's about me and I haven't said a word.'" Director John Rich was running the rehearsal, but it was veteran Natalie Schafer (Mrs. Howell) who delivered the zinger: "Didn't the name Gilligan's Island give you a clue, darling?"

From that moment on, Tina Louise felt misled and boxed in. "She didn't like Ginger. She didn't like playing Ginger. She didn't like the wigs, the gowns, the makeup, the unreality of it all," Mark explains. "She came from dramatic theater and had done serious work. Ginger was a caricature to her."

Tina Louise as Ginger Grant on Gilligan's Island

Tina Louise as Ginger Grant on Gilligan's Island

Meanwhile, the rest of the cast understood what the job meant. "The others thought, ‘Honey, it's a weekly paycheck. We're lucky to be here. We're about to become TV stars.'" But Tina remained distant. "She didn't speak to most of the cast. She wasn't on set unless she had lines. The only one she interacted with was Jim Backus," Mark reveals. "Not romantically-his wife, Alice, was very jealous-but they'd have coffee together. Alice, by the way, had hoped she would be cast as Lovey Howell."

Alice Backus even had her own claim to screen history. "Remember the original Columbia logo-the lady with the torch in the early Three Stooges shorts? That was Alice."

Credit wars and ensemble drama

Behind the curtain, agents were battling just as fiercely as the actors. While Bob Denver and Alan Hale (Skipper) naturally took the top two billing slots, Jim Backus's agent insisted he receive "special billing" due to his fame. Tina Louise's agent wanted the same. That left Russell Johnson (Professor) and Dawn Wells (Mary Ann) out in the cold.

When the original theme song was recorded (reportedly at Sherwood Schwartz's house), it didn't mention Russell or Dawn at all. "It ended with ‘…and the rest,'" Mark says. "That made Bob Denver furious." Denver saw the show as an ensemble effort and believed everyone deserved proper credit. He told producers he wouldn't return for Season 2 unless Johnson and Wells were named in the opening sequence.

This insistence would finally lead to the iconic version of the theme song that listed all seven castaways. It's one of those rare victories in TV history where the moral compass of a cast member-Denver, in this case-actually changed the shape of the show.

GILLIGAN'S ISLAND, front: Tina Louise, back: Alan Hale Jr., Bob Denver, TV GUIDE cover, June 11-17, 1966.

Gilligan's Island, front: Tina Louise, back: Alan Hale Jr., Bob Denver, TV Guide cover, June 11-17, 1966.

As for Tina, her frustrations continued. "She did her job, but she kept to herself. She wasn't social on set. She had been promised the show would revolve around her, and it didn't. And she never really let that go."

Even a promotional TV Guide cover became a battleground. "Her agent told her she'd be the only one featured. That didn't happen. Bob Denver pushed back again, saying, ‘Either everyone's on the cover, or I won't do it.'" And with the switch to color for Season 2, he insisted on the same ensemble treatment in the opening credits.

Alan Hale Jr, Tina Louise and Bob Denver in Gilligan's Island

Entertainment

See the Cast of ‘Gilligan's Island' Young, Before They Became TV Legends

Having made its television debut in 1964, viewers have been laughing at the seven stranded castaways of Gilligan's Island for the past 60 years, and for many of them their knowledge of Bob Denver, Alan Hale Jr, Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Tina Louise, Russell Johnson and Dawn Wells pretty much start and stop with the show. And […]

Behind the glamour of Lovey Howell, actress Natalie Schafer carried a private battle. "She had survived breast cancer and undergone a double mastectomy," Mark says. "All of her costumes were custom-made by Madam Swedlow of New York with built-in breasts. It was cut in a way that she wouldn't appear flat-chested."

Schafer kept her condition private, but she trusted Dawn Wells enough to share it. "They bonded early on," Mark says. "Dawn asked her why her costumes were so elaborate, and Natalie simply took off her top and showed her the surgical scars. That was Natalie: elegant, brave and kind."

Reaching the end of the ‘Island'

Despite its popularity and a solid second season, Gilligan's Island began to run out of steam creatively by year three. "What CBS feared finally started happening-they began to run out of ideas," Geoffrey Mark says. "Suddenly, Season 3 is full of visitors showing up on the island. You can get on, but you can't get off."

Behind the scenes, the show's production credit-"A Glad to See Ya Production"-was more than a catchy phrase. "That came from Phil Silvers," Mark explains. "He invested in the show. ‘Glad to see ya!' was his catchphrase, so that's why his company got the credit. And that's also why he ended up guest starring as a Hollywood director on the show-Harold Hecuba."

Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Phil Silvers, Dawn Wells, Alan Hale Jr., Bob Denver, Tina Louise, 'The Producer', season 3, ep. 4, aired 10/3/1966

Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Phil Silvers, Dawn Wells, Alan Hale Jr., Bob Denver, Tina Louise, ‘The Producer', season 3, ep. 4, aired 10/3/1966

But even with the occasional stunt casting and continued ratings success, the island's days were numbered. The real shipwreck came courtesy of Babe Paley, wife of CBS founder William S. Paley. When the network internally circulated its Fall 1967 schedule, Babe reportedly asked her husband, "Where's Gunsmoke?"

Bill Paley explained that Gunsmoke-then in its twelfth season-had been quietly retired due to declining ratings and the fading popularity of Westerns. "The Western craze was over," says Mark. "But nobody told the networks. They kept making them anyway." Babe was unmoved. "Fix it," she said.

L-R: Clayton Moore in 'The Lone Ranger,' Lorne Greene in 'Bonanza' and Kevin Costner in 'Yellowstone'

Entertainment

‘Gunsmoke' to ‘Yellowstone'-Here's a Round-up of Every Western TV Show!

Westerns have been riding tall on television since the medium's very beginning. Long before superheroes, police procedurals or reality shows took over primetime, Americans were glued to their sets watching cowboys tame the frontier, protect the homestead and keep the peace-usually with a six-shooter and a strong sense of justice. From the black-and-white morality tales […]

Paley did. To make room for Gunsmoke in a new Monday night slot-just ahead of The Lucy Show and The Andy Griffith Show-CBS canceled Gilligan's Island, despite its renewal. "It was already scheduled to come back," Mark says. "They'd even developed a pedal car and were trying to farm their own food to keep it interesting."

Worse, the cast didn't hear the news from Schwartz or CBS-they read it in the papers. "There was no phone call, no goodbye party, no closure," Mark recalls. "The only one who was happy about the cancellation was Tina Louise. And I don't want to make her out to be a bad person-just someone who was deeply unhappy with what she'd signed on for."

Still, he notes, Tina wasn't entirely unreachable. "Dawn [Wells] admired her. She admired her beauty, how she applied her makeup-Tina even taught Dawn to wear mink eyelashes."

Tina wasn't hostile, just withdrawn. "She didn't hate Dawn. She just didn't like what the show had become." Mark also shares a rare moment of levity: "There was a scene where Ginger was supposed to take a shower outdoors. Word spread across the CBS lot and every grip and lighting guy found a reason to be on set that day. But Tina? She pulled a practical joke. She didn't shoot the scene-just let everyone think she would. She got the last laugh."

A second and third life

For a show cut short without warning, Gilligan's Island managed to thrive. "Once it hit syndication, it became huge," Mark says. "Even bigger than during its original run." Like The Brady Bunch, its sister show from creator Sherwood Schwartz, Gilligan's Island became after-school comfort food for generations.

"It was clean, it was silly and it was safe," Mark reflects. "That slapstick and innocence made it perfect for kids. And Sherwood made a fortune in syndication."

The magic of syndication in the pre-cable days brought Gilligan's Island to a whole new generation long before TV Land ever existed. "This was before cable was a thing," Geoffrey Mark explains. "We're talking late '60s, '70s, even early '80s. HBO was new. If you had clear reception, you were lucky."

RESCUE FROM GILLIGAN'S ISLAND, Dawn Wells, Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Russell Johnson, Bob Denver, Alan Hale Jr., Judith Baldwin, 1978

Entertainment

The Lost Spin-offs of 'Gilligan's Island'-a Rare Look Inside

They were stranded for three seasons. Then they got rescued… twice, before deciding to go back to their island willingly. But what even diehard fans of Gilligan's Island may not know is that the show's seven castaways actually had two more adventures-ones that never aired in prime time and never reran in syndication. We're talking […]

In that era, Gilligan's Island became so popular in its afterlife that it spawned two animated spinoffs. But even in cartoon form, Tina Louise remained consistent in her distance. "Dawn [Wells] told me-and she was very clear about this-Tina wanted nothing to do with it," Mark says. "So, Dawn did double duty as Mary Ann and Ginger, doing a Tina impression for both cartoon series."

Tina also skipped all three reunion TV movies that aired in the late 1970s and early 1980s. "There was one time-just one-that they were all together again," Mark recalls. "It was during the brief run of The Late Show after Joan Rivers left. Ross Shafer, who I'm not fond of for personal reasons, hosted a Gilligan's Island reunion. For some reason, that was the only time Tina showed up."

Despite her distance, others remained close. Dawn Wells, as Mark tells it, stayed in touch with nearly everyone from the cast. "She was very close with Alan Hale Jr.," he says. "He'd come by her house often. She went to his restaurant. She was close with his granddaughter, Samantha Hale, a stand-up comedian." She was also close with Natalie Schafer and Russell Johnson, often visiting their homes.

Gilligan's Island reunion at trading card show in 1995

Actors (L-R) Dawn Wells, Russell Johnson, Tina Louise and Bob Denver from TV's Gilligan's Island at trading card show

Even Tina had moments of connection-brief as they were. "Dawn once went to Tina's house and cooked her Thanksgiving dinner," Mark says. "Tina had never hosted one before. Dawn showed her how to do it, cooked everything… and Tina never invited her back. But Tina's daughter later reached out to Dawn and said, ‘I remember that. I don't know why we never had you back, but you were so kind.'"

Time took its toll. Jim Backus developed Parkinson's. Schafer's cancer returned. Johnson, too, became very ill. "These were kind people," Mark says softly. "Talented people. A sitcom lives on its casting. The writing can be brilliant, but if you don't have the right people saying the lines, it flops."

Long Hours and hot lights

Despite its sunny tone, Gilligan's Island was a tough show to film. "It wasn't like The Lucy Show, where they shot in front of a live audience," Mark says. "This was single-camera, no audience, so, every scene had to be shot over and over-master shot, two-shot, close-ups-all under hot lights, for long hours."

And unlike most sitcoms of the time, which had three or four regulars, Gilligan's Island had seven. "That was a lot of people to cover," Mark explains. "Everyone had to be filmed from multiple angles. It made for grueling work, especially since only Dawn [Wells] was in her twenties. The others were in their 30s, 40s-even 60s."

Even the lovable Jim Backus had his quirks. "He'd go to lunch with Tina, or sometimes with Dawn and Natalie. But when it was the ladies footing the bill, he had a habit of ‘forgetting his wallet,'" Mark laughs. "He was a good man, but famously cheap."

RESCUE FROM GILLIGAN'S ISLAND, Dawn Wells, Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Russell Johnson, Bob Denver, Alan Hale Jr., Judith Baldwin, 1978

Rescue from Gilligan's Island, Dawn Wells, Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Russell Johnson, Bob Denver, Alan Hale Jr., Judith Baldwin, 1978

Backus brought a wealth of showbiz experience with him, from his Mr. Magoo voice work to films and radio-including a stint working with James Dean. "He was doing Mr. Magoo at the same time as Gilligan's Island, actually. I think there's one season where the cartoon overlapped with the first season of the show."

As Gilligan's Island gained traction in reruns, fans couldn't let go of the question: Why didn't they ever get off the island?

As noted, and with nostalgia revivals on the rise, Sherwood Schwartz decided it was time. "He'd already had success reinventing The Brady Bunch in every form imaginable," Mark says. "A variety show, cartoons, Christmas specials. So, he figured, why not Gilligan's Island?"

And so came the 1978 TV movie Rescue from Gilligan's Island, followed by The Castaways on Gilligan's Island (1979) and The Harlem Globetrotters on Gilligan's Island (1981). Tina Louise declined to return for any of them.

For longtime fans, the Gilligan's Island reunion movies offered a welcome return to familiar faces-at least initially. "The first one, Rescue from Gilligan's Island, actually worked," opines Mark. "It was warm and touching. You got to see the castaways rescued and returning to their lives. The Howells' mansion, Mary Ann's farm, Ginger on a movie set, Skipper trying to get insurance for his boat-it gave closure."

Of course, that closure didn't last. "At the end of the movie, Gilligan screws something up and they end up back on the island," Mark laughs. "By this point, The Love Boat was popular, so the next idea was the Howells invest in the island and turn it into a resort."

That idea became The Castaways on Gilligan's Island, and then the notorious The Harlem Globetrotters on Gilligan's Island. "The second movie didn't work," Mark says bluntly. "They tried to cram in five or six guest stars and give each a storyline-then match them with a castaway for resolution. But it lacked cohesion. And by the third one, you didn't have Tina and you didn't have Jim Backus, except in a brief cameo. It didn't feel right anymore."

Backus, battling Parkinson's, made only a short appearance in the final movie. His absence, and Tina Louise's continued refusal to return, cast a shadow over the productions. Dave Ruprecht was brought in to play the Howells' long-lost son-a character who, as Mark puts it, "hadn't been mentioned in 20 years." The actor did his best, but the character felt like a plot device rather than a meaningful addition.

"It could've worked," Mark says, "if they'd built a movie around the son's backstory-raised by a butler, trying to reconnect with parents he never knew-it might've had heart. But instead, it was about the Harlem Globetrotters."

Celebrate even more 'Gilligan's Island'