Zohran Mamdani at NYC Pride March 2025

Democratic mayoral nominee Zohran Mamdani has sparked controversy after calling for an end to mayoral control of New York City’s school system. He proposed a collaborative governance model involving parents, educators, and administrators. However, education experts have warned the proposal could weaken oversight in an already strained system, questioning whether his approach adequately supports families who rely on successful charter schools.

Zohran Mamdani speaking to press at Pride

Mamdani's campaign stated, “Zohran supports an end to mayoral control and envisions a system instead in which parents, students, educators and administrators work together to create the school environments in which students and families will best thrive—strengthening co-governance.”

Classroom at Wilson

Manhattan Institute senior fellow Ray Domanico stated, “It would be a terrible mistake to take away the mayor’s majority on the Panel for Education Policy.”

American Flag in Percy Priest Elementary

After winning the Democratic primary, Mamdani gained support from the United Federation of Teachers. Critics argued his policies prioritize union interests over working-class families who rely on charter schools.

Inside Percy Priest Elementary classroom

Mamdani has proposed reforms to enhance accountability and encourage community involvement through advisory boards. He voiced concerns over charter schools, citing perceived equity issues and high suspension rates.

Mayor Eric Adams at Penn Station press conference

Mayor Eric Adams’ campaign has called Mamdani’s education proposals reckless, warning that weakening mayoral control could bring back dysfunction and reduce accountability. Critics noted that key issues like enrollment declines and stagnant performance have remained largely unaddressed.

Mayor Eric Adams at Veterans Day Parade

Adams campaign spokesperson Todd Shapiro said, “It would take us back to a time when New York City’s school system was mired in dysfunction, with no clear accountability and no one in charge.”

Mayor Adams discussing security measures

Shapiro added, “While Mamdani talks about pulling power from the mayor, Mayor Adams is focused on keeping our kids learning, safe, and supported. He fought to extend mayoral control because he believes one person should be responsible—and that person is the mayor New Yorkers elect.”

Emily Prescott covers U.S. politics & news for content partner Modern Newsstand LLC.