Top 10 fast-food burgers in US ranked

Fast food fans have strong opinions – especially when it comes to burgers. In a recent Reddit thread, users shared their favorites, and the top picks stood out for flavor, consistency, and fan devotion. After excluding local joints and fast-casual spots, these 10 national fast-food burgers emerged as the most beloved among real customers.

10. In-N-Out Burger

In-N-Out is a West Coast institution with a devoted following, but not everyone’s sold on the hype. Many fans praise the chain for its quality ingredients and consistent preparation, but detractors find it underwhelming. One user said, 'It’s the best tasting burger… most consistent, and they use legitimate ingredients', while another claimed: '[It is] not even better than Steak n Shake.' Despite the debate, In-N-Out earns a spot for the passion it inspires – on both sides.

9. McDonald’s Big Mac

Even the most iconic fast food chain isn’t immune to criticism. Many Reddit users were quick to criticize McDonald’s for offering bland, undersized burgers that don’t hold up to competitors. However, the Big Mac stood out as the lone exception. 'The only burger I like from there is the Big Mac, and honestly it’s just the Mac sauce,' one Redditor wrote. It’s clear that the signature sauce is doing a lot of heavy lifting, but that’s enough to keep the Big Mac in the conversation.

8. Sonic Drive-In SuperSONIC Double Cheeseburger

Sonic’s appeal lies in its retro, drive-in vibes and solid burger lineup – at least when everything’s made right. The consensus is that Sonic can be great if you know what to order and catch it on a good day. 'That new smash burger from Sonic is pretty flippin tasty,' said one Redditor, while another recommended the 'double cheeseburger with bacon.' The overall impression? A great value option that doesn’t always hit the mark, but satisfies when it does.

7. Burger King Double Whopper

Burger King earns praise for its budget-friendly pricing and flame-grilled flavor. Fans frequently mentioned the Double Whopper as a standout, especially for the price. 'Burger King has the bang for the buck… the double whopper with bacon and cheese meal is like $12,' said one Redditor. However, not everyone is convinced of its consistency, as another user warned: 'BK quality is WILDLY inconsistent.'

6. Carl’s Jr. Western Bacon Cheeseburger

Carl’s Jr. stands out for its big, bold flavors – especially its Western Bacon Cheeseburger. Users highlighted the burger’s indulgent toppings and satisfying size. If you’re looking for something messy and satisfying, Carl’s Jr. delivers on the fast-food decadence.

Top 10 fast-food burgers in US ranked

Shake Shack is known for premium ingredients and elevated taste, but it comes at a cost. While many Reddit users love the flavor, they aren’t thrilled about the prices. As one user summed it up: 'That smoke shack is fire but spendy.' Great if you’re willing to splurge.

4. Five Guys Cheeseburger

Five Guys is often hailed as the best-tasting burger in fast food, but affordability is another story. Many fans are willing to pay the premium, calling it unmatched in flavor. 'Five Guys is by far the best. Expensive but 100% the best,' claimed one user. However, others felt the price point excluded it from the category altogether. Still, for those who don’t mind shelling out a bit more, it’s a top-tier option.

3. Wendy’s Baconator

Wendy’s delivers a consistent winner in the Baconator. This burger’s reputation for flavor and reliability earned it a spot near the top of the list. 'The Baconator is amazing every time,' gushed one Redditor. With a generous amount of bacon and a hearty beef patty, the Baconator nails the fast-food formula with style.

2. Whataburger Patty Melt

Whataburger may not be available nationwide, but those who’ve had it swear by it. Fans love its distinct regional flavor and generous portion sizes. 'Whataburger Patty Melt, sweet and spicy bacon burger… some of my favorites,' said one user and another even compared its reputation to In-N-Out. For those in the know, Whataburger is nothing short of fast-food royalty.

1. Culver's ButterBurger

At the top of the heap is Culver’s ButterBurger, a Midwestern staple that customers adore for its taste, quality, and value. It consistently outshines other chains with its made-to-order approach and seasoned patties. 'Culver’s 100%. Nothing is really even close IMO,' declared one fan. Another wrote: 'Culver’s has better burgers than 99% of non fast food restaurants as well. And the seasoning? It’s the seasoning that makes the burgers smack.'